Skip to main content

Was Gandhi truly a Racist or Pedophile?

Who is Gandhi?

"Mahatma Gandhi, full name "Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi" was an Indian lawyer, politician, social activist, and writer who became the leader of the nationalist movement against the British rule of India"


We need to be careful about what we think we know of an icon. History is an evidence-based pursuit, not an opinion-founded political football. To get closer to the truth, we need to look at evidence.

Was Gandhi racist?

By contemporary standards, the answer is a resounding "yes" - and quite probably a "no" too. Like all people, Gandhi was not a god. He was just a man and as human as any of us. But he did say things that were bigoted against other races.

Timelines

South Africa

In his younger days, Gandhi spent 21 years practicing as a lawyer in South Africa. Many of his statements then, although probably normal at the time, seem extremely bigoted and shocking now.

The Natal Indian Congress was formed on August 22, 1894 with the primary objective declared to be to: "To promote concord and harmony among the Indians and Europeans in the Colony." No mention of Africans or other Asians.

Kaffirs

In 1896, for example, he stated: 


"Ours is one continued struggle against degradation sought to be inflicted upon us by the European, who desire to degrade us to the level of the raw Kaffir*, whose occupation is hunting and whose sole ambition is to collect a certain number of cattle to buy a wife with, and then pass his life in indolence and nakedness." 


In a letter later published in The Indian Opinion, Gandhi said, "Why, of all places in Johannesburg, the Indian location should be chosen for dumping down all kaffirs of the town, passes my comprehension. Of course, under my suggestion, the Town Council must withdraw the Kaffirs from the Location. About this mixing of the Kaffirs with the Indians I must confess I feel most strongly. I think it is very unfair to the Indian population, and it is an undue tax on even the proverbial patience of my countrymen." As it turned out, other Indians had sub-letted the property to black Africans. Purity of race

"We believe as much in the purity of race as we think they do, only we believe that they would best serve these interests, which are as dear to us as to them, by advocating the purity of all races, and not one alone. We believe also that the white race of South Africa should be the predominating race." This seems to be arguing for racial purity in addition to white supremacy. If Hitler or Churchill made the same statement, would this not make you feel uncomfortable?

Raising a real army

There are many other similar statements made by Gandhi in this period. According to one author, G.B. Singh, Gandhi raised an Indian army regiment to fight against the black Zulu. This conflicts with the modern image of Gandhi as an entirely non-violent person.

Caste as a basis for racism?


Singh's argument is that Gandhi's ideology of caste made it simple for him to automatically relegate black Africans to the role of dalit, hence his discomfiture at being classified as one. Personally, I think more evidence is probably needed, but it's not impossible.

The role of history proving his malevolent acts?

As Joe Geronimo Martinez said, it's harsh to judge people by what they said long ago and unfair, even if they clearly said things uncomfortable by our standards. Gandhi's philosophy was still in development. It would be hard to argue that equality for all people, even dalits and black Africans, is not a part of it (though some do).

But we can conclude that we are all human. Even figures as towering as Gandhi displayed a bigotry towards other human beings that is unacceptable now. For a lot of his life, Gandhi was only all too human, just like the rest of us. Answers to the question, Was Winston Churchill a racist? If so, how did his racist attitudes influence his policies in India, the Middle East, etc.? If not, what is some counter evidence to all the racist quotes that have been attributed to him? argue that racism was not uncommon in those days. The evidence of Gandhi's racism gives us cause to believe that.

The one lesson we can learn is to be careful in our judgments of history: Hopefully, future generations might be as considerate to us.

Because I guarantee, one day people will look at us too and say, "WTF!"



Please refer below article of ibTimes which highlights few allegations against him:

Gandhi 'Slept With Grandniece', Historian Tells UK Government


After his death, for all political reasons Congress party and his followers manipulated such wrong things around him and tried their best to keep his image completely clean. Otherwise, it would have been difficult to defend his status as ‘Father of Nation.'

But such incidents are linked with many other world famous figures, but their followers buried those shortcomings because of their massive contribution to humanity.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Do We Scratch Our Heads When We're Thinking?

Some people believe that certain automatic gestures — like scratching our heads when we're thinking — are natural motions that were passed down to us from our caveman predecessors. JOSE LUIS PELAEZ INC./GETTY IMAGES If you've ever had the distinct pleasure of sourcing stock photos for any reason, you've likely come across a whole lot of laughing women eating salads alone . But you've also probably stumbled upon a truckload of people scratching their heads to symbolize confusion, deep thought and/or perhaps a bad case of seborrheic dermatitis — dandruff. Scalp dryness aside, how exactly did the head scratch come to symbolize intellectual processes? Some people believe that certain automatic gestures are simply natural, expressive motions our caveman predecessors passed down to us. "One popular explanation for any hand-to-head movements is that they're frustrated aggression — a reversion to the natural movements of our rock-throwing ancestors," wrote Sa...

In 1884, a Ship Was Discovered Totally Abandoned … and the Crew Was Never Found by Kate Kershner Aug 30, 2017

While it would be really cool if there were tons of legitimate historical reports of faintly glowing apparitions of ships and sailors, there are many more stories about something less metaphysical but still pretty creepy: ships that were abandoned without an apparent cause or trace. On this episode of the Stuff You Missed in History Class podcast, hosts Holly Frey and Tracy V. Wilson tell us a few tales of the bottomless blue and the ships that sailed them — and washed up on some shore entirely deserted. If that sounds like a fairly routine course of events for ships of yore, you might be surprised to learn how weird the circumstances of these incidents were. Take the Resolven, a cargo ship that traveled between Canada and Wales in the late 19th century. In 1884, some sailors spotted it off the coast of what is now Newfoundland and Labrador. The ship was moving haphazardly through the water, and when the sailors boarded the Resolven they saw why. While the sails were set, there wasn...

Tips to improve your self discipline

What is self-discipline? Some words in the English language brings the same heady mix of youthful enthusiasm, stubborn rebellion, and a vague sense of “should-be-doing-better” guilt like self-discipline.  “Self-discipline is the ability to organise our behaviour over time in the service of specific tasks… It requires the ability to defer gratification in the service of a remote goal. This is the ability to think, plan and live long-range.” – Nathaniel Branden I don’t know about you, but I’ve had my own (not-exactly-positive) associations with self-discipline, and I wish there was another word to describe this quality that wasn’t quite so… off-putting. But here we are. Self-discipline is helpful. It enables us to get s— done. It helps to build our self-esteem (actions aligned with principled goals = higher self-esteem). Depending on where we practice self-discipline within our lives, it leaves us healthier, more learned, more self-aware, higher performing, more s...